What We Need

Granny DReading time – 126 seconds  .  .  .

Doris Haddock is not a well known name, but you might know her as Granny D. She saw clearly the corrupting influence of big money in our politics and on our country and determined to do something about it. To draw attention to this issue she set out on a 3,200 mile walk across America, from California all the way to Washington DC. When she began this brave journey on January 1, 1999 she was 88 years old. When she completed it on February 29, 2000 she was 90.

Granny D saw something that ever-more Americans are seeing, that our democracy is in grave danger due to the dishonesty and inequality inherent in our present election system. Whatever issue is of greatest importance to you, be it global warming, gun safety, human rights, international trade, voting rights, immigration, fracking or any of the vexing challenges before this nation, big money in our politics is the mother of the dysfunction that prevents solutions from being implemented and allows things to steadily get worse.

We have massive unemployment and, every bit as bad, massive under-employment. We have brilliant people who cannot find a job. Perhaps that is an issue that you don’t deeply feel just now, but when your knees go bad, you will wish that some truly gifted person had been working in a lab and had found a way to re-grow the cartilage in your joints. When you contract cancer, as so many of us will, you will wish that one of our people with a head full of amazing potential had been able to get the education that might have led to a cure. When your adult children are living in your basement, burdened by overwhelming school debt and without a chance for a job, you will wish that our politicians did more than tell us that it’s all about jobs, jobs, jobs. You’ll wish they had done something about it.

Both Pew Research and the Gallup Organization have done polling on how we Americans feel about our government. The staggering truth is that 81 of every 100 Americans does not trust our government. In recent years one of the biggest trust killers has been the growing economic disparity between the rich and all the rest of us and that is aggravated largely by money-driven political actions and inaction.

Elections are insanely expensive, largely due to the cost of television and radio advertising. The 2012 presidential contest alone cost $2.1 billion. The senate contest in Massachusetts between Elizabeth Warren and Scott Brown cost $77 million and the current senatorial contest in Kentucky looks like it will cost over $100 million. About 75% of that money will come from outside the state, meaning that the decision on the next senator from Kentucky will be driven largely by very rich people who don’t even live in Kentucky but who want to ensure a senate that does their bidding.

Don’t imagine that all politicians are dishonest because that simply is not true. On the other hand, it is impossible to raise enough money to mount a serious campaign in most federal elections if money is raised solely through small contributions from local citizens. That leaves candidates having to solicit large contributions from big donors. Another way to say that is that the system requires that anyone who wants to serve must put themselves in a position of becoming beholden to rich benefactors. And that is the problem.

In a study done by Larry Bartels of the Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs, it was found that only wealthy constituents gain the ear of their elected officials. Nobody is listening to the rest of us, so rich people get what they want and everyone else goes wanting.

A study done by Gilens and Page found exactly the same thing about policy making. And these studies have proven with research what every American has known for decades. The problem is that the situation continues to become worse and is bringing us to an America that almost none of us wants.

People in power rarely give up their power unless they have no alternative – that’s just human nature. They have engineered a system that keeps people afraid of speaking up for fear of losing what little they have managed to secure for themselves. But while part-time work at minimum wage and with no benefits can be tolerated for a while, there will come a time when the patience of the American people will run out, when people simply won’t have it any longer. We the people will let the politicians know that if they want to serve, they must serve us.

If 81% of us don’t trust our government, that is not a partisan issue. If 90% of us believe that there is way too much money sloshing around our political system, that is not a partisan issue. If for many years nearly all the economic gains have gone to the richest 1% of Americans, that is not a partisan issue. We really are all on the same side of this.

It is time to wake up. It is time to stop ridiculing the Occupy Wall Street crowd just because they don’t have a formal hierarchy and a central organization. It is time to stop ridiculing Tea Party people just because some of them are flamboyant. The words may sound different, but the demands of those two very different groups are remarkably similar regarding money in politics. It is time to unite as Americans, left, center and right.

Granny D was correct: When we solve the big money problem, we’ll be ready to solve all the rest. And that is what 99% of Americans want.


Ed. note: There is much in America that needs fixing and we are on a path to continually fail to make things better. It is my goal to make a difference – perhaps to be a catalyst for things to get better. That is the reason for these posts. To accomplish the goal requires reaching many thousands of people and a robust dialogue. Please help by offering your comments, as well as by passing this along and encouraging others to subscribe and do the same.  Thanks.  JA

Copyright 2024 by Jack Altschuler
Reproduction and sharing are encouraged, providing proper attribution is given.

What do you think?

Your name and e-mail address are required, but your e-mail will not be disclosed.

Keep the conversation going by both adding your comments and by passing this along to three friends.
That´s how things get better.

3 Responses to What We Need
  1. Frank Levy Reply

    It may be true, and polls may show that “81 of every 100 Americans does not trust our government.” It may also be true that the Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs found that only wealthy constituents gain the ear of their elected officials.

    We may all believe that nobody in Congress is listening to the rest of us, so rich people get what they want and everyone else goes wanting.

    But I am afraid that the reality is, if current polls for the 2014 mid-term elections are correct, that Congress is not listening to us, because we are not voting and telling THEM what we want with our votes. How can democratic, progressive, liberal, and socialist voters not be voting in such large numbers that even the tone deaf Republican Party will have to pay attention to our need to protect and preserve the First Amendment, voting rights, a women’s right to choose, access to adequate health care and contraception, Social Security, Medicare, the Affordable Care Act, enact immigration reform, increase the minimum wage, and most important, preserve the Democratic Majority in the Senate to President Obama has the opportunity to name a liberal Supreme Court justice before his term ends if need be.

    If nothing else, this election is about the Supreme Court.

    If the those of us who oppose big money in politics, and republican and Libertarian ideas and politics don’t vote we deserve to be ignored. We deserve the government we get.

    Jack, I agree with all that you have presented above, but you are Don Quixote tilting at the windmill of apathy my friend. Just look at the polls.

    • JaxPolitix Reply

      Let me play with your words just a bit: We deserve the government we tolerate. We can only tolerate injustice for a while; then it becomes intolerable.

      The time will come when, as I wrote and paraphrasing Thom Hartmann, when the American people simply won’t have it any more, when our frustration will have piled up so high over unmet needs that we the people will demand reform. History has shown us time and again that this is so.

      But, again, as I wrote, people do not give up power willingly, so reform may get dangerous. Our own revolution and that of the French just a few years afterward are easy examples. The Civil War was fought, in part, because people who had economic power refused to give up some of it. But the time had come when the people simply wouldn’t have it any more. I do not advocate nor do I want violence. My point is that people can be kept down only so long. Then they will demonstrate their demands.

      So, I may be Don Quixote tilting at windmills just now, but there will be a future and people will see that what had looked like windmills was really the mountain of injustice that had to come down.

  2. David Houle Reply

    Great column and to the point. Our great nation is politically dysfunctional, putting the long term legacy of our greatness at risk.

    If we don’t start to stand up and soon, then the plutocracy will act in ways that will most certainly trigger demonstrations, revolt and rebellion. History doe not lie.